The Huawei Mate 9 Reviewby Matt Humrick on January 27, 2017 7:00 AM EST
Flagship phones give manufacturers the opportunity to showcase their latest technology, and because they attract attention and generate buzz, they help raise brand awareness. For Huawei, currently the world’s third largest smartphone producer by market share, its Mate series of phones is the pinnacle of what the company has to offer. And while the Mate 9, the successor to the Mate 8 that we looked at in-depth last year, packs some high-end hardware, Huawei recognizes it takes more than an impressive spec sheet to win the premium smartphone battle; it needs to provide an overall experience and image that matches the phone’s premium price.
Performance and responsiveness are important for any phone, but essential for a flagship like the Mate 9. Making its debut inside the Mate 9’s aluminum chassis is HiSilicon’s new Kirin 960 SoC. The four ARM Cortex-A72 CPUs in the Mate 8’s Kirin 950 have been replaced by four of ARM’s latest Cortex-A73 CPUs. The plus-one change in model number is deceptive, however, because there are some significant differences between the two cores. The A73 actually belongs to a different processor family, with its roots going back to the A17 rather than branching out from the A15/A57/A72 family tree. One of the obvious differences between the two different microarchitectures is a reduction in decoder width: The A72 has a 3-wide decoder while the A73 is 2-wide. Despite what appears to be a reduction in capability on paper, ARM claims the A73 still offers better performance and efficiency relative to A72 on the same process and frequency. Four Cortex-A53 cores complete the big.LITTLE CPU configuration.
The Mate 9’s CPU cores reach higher peak frequencies than those in the Mate 8 too, but the differences are small. The A53 cores get a negligible increase from 1.80GHz to 1.84GHz, while the A73 cores reach up to 2.36GHz versus the 2.3GHz for the Kirin 950’s A72 cores. It’s interesting that Kirin 960’s A73 cores are clocked lower than the Kirin 955’s 2.5GHz A72 cores, especially considering that ARM targets a peak frequency of 2.8GHz on 16nm (the Kirin 960 uses TSMC’s 16FFC FinFET process). With the Kirin 960, HiSilicon is more focused on reducing power consumption (and freeing up thermal headroom for the GPU) instead of chasing maximum CPU performance. Still, based on the A73’s other advantages, particularly the improvements to the memory subsystem, the Kirin 960 should still show a small performance gain relative to Kirin 950/955.
Mate 8 (bottom) and Mate 9 (top)
Perhaps the biggest criticism of past Kirin SoCs were their seemingly underpowered GPUs. While Qualcomm pushed the performance and power envelope with its Adreno GPUs, and Samsung added eight- or twelve-core configurations of ARM’s latest Mali GPUs to its Exynos SoCs, HiSilicon’s Kirin SoCs made due with more modest four-core Mali configurations. Peak performance significantly trailed its peers, but Kirin’s lower power consumption limited the effects of thermal throttling (a significant problem for the faster GPUs). Ultimately, performance was “good enough” for the majority of cases.
The Mate 9’s Kirin 960 SoC marks a radical shift in HiSilicon’s GPU philosophy. Not only does it utilize ARM’s latest Mali-G71 GPU based on the all-new Bifrost architecture, but it steps up to an eight-core configuration running at an impressive 900MHz—the same peak frequency used by the Kirin 950/955’s much smaller GPU. The combination of additional cores and architectural improvements give the Mate 9 a significant peak performance advantage over the Mate 8’s Mali-T880MP4 GPU, paving the way for new capabilities such as VR.
|Huawei Mate 9 Series|
|Huawei Mate 9||Huawei Mate 9 Pro||Huawei Mate 9 Porsche Design|
|SoC||HiSilicon Kirin 960
4x Cortex-A53 @ 1.84GHz
4x Cortex-A73 @ 2.36GHz
ARM Mali-G71 MP8 @ 1037MHz
|Display||5.9-inch 1920x1080 IPS LCD||5.5-inch 2560x1440 AMOLED (curved edges)|
|Dimensions||156.9 x 78.9 x 7.9 mm
|152.0 x 75.0 x 7.5 mm
|RAM||4GB LPDDR4||6GB LPDDR4|
|NAND||64GB (UFS 2.1)
|128GB (UFS 2.1)
|256GB (UFS 2.1)
|Battery||4000 mAh (15.28 Wh)
|Front Camera||8MP, 1/3.2" Sony IMX179 Exmor R, 1.4µm pixels, f/1.9, Contrast AF|
|Rear Camera||Color: 12MP, 1/2.9” Sony IMX286 Exmor RS, 1.25µm pixels, f/2.2, PDAF + Laser AF + Contrast AF + Depth, OIS, HDR, dual-tone LED flash
Monochrome: 20MP, f/2.2, dual-tone LED flash
|Modem||HiSilicon LTE (Integrated)
2G / 3G / 4G LTE (Category 12/13)
|SIM Size||2x NanoSIM (dual standby) (MHA-L29)
1x NanoSIM (MHA-L09)
|Wireless||802.11a/b/g/n/ac, BT 4.2 LE, NFC, IrLED, GPS/Glonass/Galileo/BDS|
|Connectivity||USB 2.0 Type-C, 3.5mm headset|
|Sensors||capacitive fingerprint, accelerometer, gyroscope, compass, ambient light, proximity, Hall effect, barometer|
|Launch OS||Android 7.0 with EMUI 5.0|
|Launch Price||$600 US / 699 Euro||1,395 Euro|
The Mate 9 pairs its SoC with 4GB of LPDDR4 RAM, which is now standard for flagship phones. Internal storage is limited to 64GB, unlike the Mate 8 that offered a choice between 32GB, 64GB, or 128GB of NAND. Both the Mate 9 Pro (128GB) and Mate 9 Porsche Design (256GB) come with additional storage, and all three Mate 9 versions have a slot for a microSD card to expand storage further.
Software features and configuration are also vitally important to performance. The Mate 9, like previous Huawei phones, includes several enhancements to help apps launch faster and keep the system feeling more responsive. Huawei’s EMUI uses the F2FS filesystem and other optimizations to improve storage performance. There’s also Huawei’s “Machine Learning algorithm” that prioritizes system resources (CPU, memory, and storage) to improve responsiveness and overall performance. This feature, which runs locally on the phone, monitors app usage, taking note of which apps are used at what times, and then anticipates the user’s needs, by preloading the predicted app, for example. Android already manages memory usage, evicting background apps to free up resources for active processes, but Huawei takes this further by closing memory-intensive background apps to ensure memory is available for prioritized apps. It also uses compression to increase the amount of data held in working memory.
Before we discuss the Mate 9’s other hardware and features, let’s briefly cover its connectivity options. It supports 802.11a/b/g/n/ac Wi-Fi (2.4GHz and 5GHz), but only a single spatial stream enabling up to a 433Mbps PHY rate on a 80MHz channel. Most flagship phones (HTC 10, LG G5, Motorola Moto Z / Moto Z Force Droid, Samsung Galaxy S7, and iPhone 7 to name just a few) offer dual spatial stream MU-MIMO, so the Mate 9 is a bit behind here. It does come with Bluetooth 4.2 LE, NFC, and even an IR blaster, though.
The Kirin 960 includes a brand new HiSilicon LTE UE Category 12/13 modem that achieves speeds of up to 600 Mbps on the downlink and 150 Mbps on the uplink (2x20MHz carrier aggregation with 64-QAM). This new modem, which drops HiSilicon’s ‘Balong' branding, supports up to 8 data streams on the downlink using a combination of quad carrier aggregation (4x CA) and 4x4 MIMO (only for 2x CA). It also supports up to 256-QAM but not on all 8 streams. This gives it some flexibility in how it achieves its maximum throughput: (2x20MHz CA + 4x4 MIMO at 64-QAM) or (4x20MHz CA + 2x2 MIMO at 64-QAM).
|Frequency Band Support|
|FDD-LTE||1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 7 / 8 / 9 / 12 / 17 / 18 / 19 / 20 / 26 / 28 / 29||1 / 2 / 3 / 4 / 5 / 7 / 8 / 9 / 12 / 17 / 18 / 19 / 20 / 26 / 28 / 29|
|TDD-LTE||38 / 39 / 40||38 / 39 / 40 / 41|
|GSM||850 / 900 / 1800 / 1900 MHz||850 / 900 / 1800 / 1900 MHz|
|WCDMA||1 / 2 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 8 / 19||1 / 2 / 4 / 5 / 6 / 8 / 19|
|CDMA||-||BC0 (China Telecom)|
|TD-CDMA||34 / 39||34 / 39|
This modem gains another new capability: It now supports CDMA, which is important for carrier compatibility in China, and puts HiSilicon in the same group as Intel, MediaTek, and Qualcomm for global network support. This modem represents a significant investment by HiSilicon, because it uses a completely new, custom design that does not use CEVA LTE IP like previous Balong modems.
There are two different models of the Mate 9. The MHA-L09 model uses a single NanoSIM and does not support CDMA networks. The MHA-L29 model supports Dual SIM Dual Standby (DSDS), although one NanoSIM slot is shared with microSD, so it can use either two NanoSIM cards or one NanoSIM and one microSD card. The second SIM supports 2G/3G operation using GSM (850/900/1800/1900MHz), CDMA (BC0), and WCDMA (1/2/4/5/6/8/19).
Post Your CommentPlease log in or sign up to comment.
View All Comments
Meteor2 - Friday, January 27, 2017 - linkFirst off -- excellent review Matt! Best I've read on Anandtech for a very long time. I particularly liked the software section, which is so often overlooked but of course utterly crucial to the experience of using a phone.
Second; gosh the A73 is good. If only it was being made with TSMC's '10nm' process, as I believe the Snapdragon 835 is. The use of a smaller process will undoubtedly flatter the 835. That Bifrost GPU is pretty good too.
But where is the A35? Should it have not replaced the A53 by now? It's conspicuously MIA...
Ariknowsbest - Saturday, January 28, 2017 - linkThe A35 is more of an A5 replacement, while A53 is A7 replacement. The A35 makes sense in a watch or IoT, or instead of low clock A53 in little.little configuration.
Meteor2 - Saturday, January 28, 2017 - linkMy understanding is that the A35 is a better 'follow-on' to the A7 than the A53 was, just as the A72 is a much better follow-up to the A15 than the A57 was. It seems to me that maybe the SoC companies don't see the A35 as such a worthwhile investment as the A72 is. Perhaps we'll see it at the next process node.
masimilianzo - Friday, January 27, 2017 - linksince the modem in Kirin 960 supports 4x4 MIMO I guess there are actually 4 antennas on the Mate right? All future phones with Kirin 960 should support 4x4 then?
Matt Humrick - Friday, January 27, 2017 - linkYes, the Mate 9 has 4 cellular antennas. Other phones with Kirin 960 would still need the front-end components to enable 4x4 MIMO.
masimilianzo - Saturday, January 28, 2017 - linkThanks for the reply! Is 4x4 MIMO on Mate 9 enabled at the software level? the S7 has 4x4 MIMO hardware but it shipped without support for it. Thanks
joms_us - Friday, January 27, 2017 - linkI am more thrilled to see Le Pro 3 here. Thank you so much Anandtech!
Le Pro 3 was deliverately ignored or given unacceptable score by other review sites.
joms_us - Friday, January 27, 2017 - linkWould you please tell us more about how the Le Pro 3 achieved electrifying speed of 1.38 hours charging time? Did you use the default charger? Did you do the charging while the phone is off?
Peaceinvt - Saturday, January 28, 2017 - linkWhen is anyone going to mention that the Huawei phones do not support Band 30?. AT&T is using band 30 more and more and it is disingenuous to suggest an AT &T customer can buy a phone without band 30 support. So many phone reviews are cramp, ignoring glaring problems and not teaching the consumer anything by leaving this stuff out. If you are an AT&T customer and live anywhere outside of a big city, DON'T GET FOOLED BY THIS BEAUTIFUL PHONE!. I want a Huawei badly, but just have to wait. However, it doesn't help that the pros won't force manufacturers to make a product people can use by pointing out the glaring faults. Sorry, Huawei...please support band 30 to compete in the US!
1_rick - Saturday, January 28, 2017 - linkNow just imagine how all us poor Sprint users feel after every review!